FWC: Deficient harassment investigation results in constructive dismissal

Website article images (31)

In a recent decision, the Fair Work Commission (Commission) ruled that a worker was unfairly dismissed after her employer mishandled her sexual harassment complaint and failed to provide a timely and transparent investigation outcome. The case of Sewell v dnata Airport Services Pty Limited [2025] FWC 2823 serves as a cautionary tale for employers about the serious consequences of a deficient response to workplace harassment.

Key facts

The applicant, Ms Sewell, worked at Perth Airport for dnata Airport Services Pty Limited, providing passenger services to Emirates airline. Her resignation followed an incident in which a male colleague made inappropriate and repeated comments about her appearance and clothing ahead of a social event. He allegedly suggested she wear “a hijab with a short mini skirt” because it would “look good on her”, continuing to press the matter despite Ms Sewell’s clear discomfort.

The impact on Ms Sewell’s mental health was immediate and visible, prompting two female colleagues to encourage her to report the incident. On 9 March 2025, she did so via email to her duty manager and followed up two days later seeking an update. In her email, she emphasized the serious toll the incident had taken on her wellbeing and her right to a safe workplace.

Ms Sewell later learned the male employee had become angry and aggressive when informed of a second complaint; one he wrongly believed came from her. Concerned for her safety, Ms Sewell requested alternative shifts to avoid working with the employee. Dnata failed to accommodate this, citing difficulties in maintaining her flexible work arrangements.

Despite making the initial report in early March, dnata only verbally informed Ms Sewell that the investigation had concluded on 10 April 2025. She did not receive a written outcome until 28 April 2025, which stated that dnata was “unable to make a finding for some of the allegations raised”. The Commission noted that this language lacked clarity and failed to communicate whether her allegations had been substantiated.

Key findings

Deputy President Abbey Beaumont found that dnata’s failure to properly communicate the investigation outcome, both in terms of timing and substance, directly led to Ms Sewell’s resignation. The Commission held that the employer’s failure to prevent Ms Sewell from being rostered with the male employee, despite her complaints, placed her in an untenable position, which effectively forced her out of her role to protect her own safety.

Importantly, the Commission rejected dnata’s argument that Ms Sewell had voluntarily resigned, instead finding that she had been unfairly dismissed due to the employer’s actions, or lack thereof.

Deputy President Beaumont stressed that even in cases where there are no witnesses, employers must not default to a finding that allegations are ‘unsubstantiated’ simply because versions of events differ. Investigators must assess credibility, context, and the totality of evidence.

Ultimately, the Commission found that Ms Sewell has been unfairly dismissed and awarded her compensation of nearly $36,500.

Key takeaways

It is important to note that legal compliance in sexual harassment investigations goes beyond ticking procedural boxes. Employers must treat complaints seriously, act promptly and ensure communication is respectful and clear.

Further, this case serves as a timely reminder that even where an employee resigns, the Commission may still deem the resignation an unfair dismissal if the employer’s conduct makes continued employment untenable.

To mitigate the risk of a constructive dismissal, particularly when an employee raises a complaint relating to sexual harassment, employers should consider:

  • providing timely updates on investigation progress and clearly communicating outcomes in writing.
  • accommodating reasonable requests by complainants, particularly where the request relates to safety (e.g., a request not to be rostered to work with the perpetrator of sexual harassment).
  • assessing the totality of the evidence gathered, including the plausibility and consistency of accounts as opposed to simply rendering a complaint ‘unprovable’ because there are no witnesses.
  • where practicable, supporting frontline managers to respond promptly and sensitively to complaints relating to sexual harassment as opposed to adopting an ad hoc approach which may lead to the complaint not being properly addressed.

Learn more

If you require assistance in managing harassment complaints in the workplace or would simply like to discuss matters addressed in this article, please contact NRA Legal for a confidential discussion on 1800 572 679.

Sewell v dnata Airport Services Pty Limited [2025] FWC 2823 (22 September 2025)

Contact our team today